330-867-5309
Quick Search
Join Sign In
Buy Sell Realtors & Company
  • Contact Us
    Careers
    Reviews
    Our Story
    Leadership Team
  • Offices

    Want more information on our offices? Select an office below.


  • Find A Realtor

    Already working with an Realtor or have one in mind? Search below.


Communities
Services Cash Advantage
Quick Home Search
All Regions Northeast Ohio Columbus & Central Ohio Cincinnati & Northern Kentucky
Real Estate Agent Carie Igel

Carie Igel

REALTOR®
Cell: (614) 668-4996
Contact Me Visit My Website
Save To Your Contacts
Make Preferred Realtor
Designations ?
  • ABR®Accredited Buyer's Representative®
  • ALCAccredited Land Consultant
  • ASPAccredited Staging Professional®
  • AHWDAt Home With Diversity
  • AHWD®At Home With Diversity®
  • CCIMCertified Commercial Investment Member
  • CDPECertified Distressed Property Expert®
  • CIDCertified Interior Decorator
  • CIPSCertified International Property Specialist
  • CIASCertified Investor Agent Specialist
  • CNECertified Negotiation Expert
  • CPM®Certified Property Manager®
  • CRBCertified Real Estate Brokerage Manager
  • CRENCertified Real Estate Negotiator
  • CRETSCertified Real Estate Team Specialist
  • CRSCertified Residential Specialist
  • CRE™Counselor of Real Estate™
  • GAAGeneral Accredited Appraiser
  • GRIGraduate, REALTOR® Institute
  • HHSHistoric House Specialist
  • MBAMaster of Business Administration
  • MRPMilitary Relocation Professional
  • GREENNAR's Green Designation
  • e-PRO®NAR's real estate technology certification
  • PMNPerformance Management Network
  • PSAProperty Strategy Advisor
  • RCEREALTOR® Association Certified Executive
  • RAAResidential Accredited Appraiser
  • RSPSResort & Second-Home Property Specialist
  • SRSSeller Representative Specialist
  • SRES®Seniors Real Estate Specialist®
  • SFR®Short Sales & Foreclosure Resource®
  • SIORSociety of Industrial and Office REALTORS®

NINJA CERTIFIED™

Specialties

Residential

Interests

Dog Lover, Family, Sports Enthusiast

Biography

Cutler Real Estate asked Carrie a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Carrie's replies.

1. What is your professional/educational background?

  • I am from Columbus and attended Northside Christian School
  • Ohio State University 1994-1999 and studied Textile Sciences
  • Real Estate Education at Hondros College, have taken the Broker Education at Hondros and just need to take the Broker test

2. Why did you choose a career in real estate?

My husband and I relocated from Milwaukee, Wisconsin back to the Columbus area and our Realtor recruited me into the business.

3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live?

We live in Scioto Run, where Dublin, Hilliard, and UA all come together inside of 270. We love our neighborhood and the location as it is close proximity to the highway and getting everywhere we need to go.

4. How do you spend your free time?

In my free time, I am constantly striving to stay connected with my husband as we chase our kids to their activities, and find time to spend with family and friends. We entertain a lot, attend Columbus Crew games, enjoy eating out, and spend lots of time at the horse barn with our girls.

5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be?

  1. Dog
  2. Wedding ring
  3. Car for transportation

Everything else can go as long as I have my family with me

6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you?

Kind, thoughtful, giving, loving, generous, organized

Full BioLess Bio
$975,000 Active 5164 Riverway Run
Powell, OH 43065 0 beds 0 baths sqft mls 226010213
$725,000 Closed Listed at $698,000 3818 Riverwatch Lane
Columbus, OH 43221 4 beds 3.1 baths 3,784 sqft mls 226014389 Buyer Represented $387,500 Closed Listed at $395,000 4858 Wallington Drive
Hilliard, OH 43026 3 beds 1.1 baths 1,608 sqft mls 226015372 Seller Represented $1,950,021 Closed Listed at $1,825,000 7040 Bordeaux Court
Dublin, OH 43016 5 beds 4.1 baths 9,832 sqft mls 225041622 Both Represented
VIEW ALL SOLD LISTINGS
5/5 Based On 24 Ratings
ADD TESTIMONIAL
5.0/5 Based On 10 Ratings
Jun 08, 2026
Property
3818 Riverwatch Lane, Columbus, Ohio, 43221
We had a great experience working with Carie in recent our home search. Starting with the initial meeting, she took the time to understand what we were looking for and helped us find a beautiful home in a wonderful neighborhood close to our daughter and her family. She exceeded our expectations. Carie handled every detail with care and professionalism, making the complicated process of buying a home feel smooth and well-organized. She was consistently responsive. She answered all of our questions quickly and clearly, which made us feel supported at every step. One of the things we appreciated most was her network of trusted service providers. Her recommendations were excellent and helped us transition into our new home without the hassle of finding reliable help on our own. Overall, Carie made the entire experience significantly less stressful and far more enjoyable than we expected. We are truly grateful for her guidance and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, attentive, and dependable real estate agent.
-- Dante Bonaquist
Jun 07, 2026
Property
3818 Riverwatch Lane, Columbus, Ohio, 43221
Carie is an outstanding realtor! She came highly recommended by our daughter and we are so glad we chose her to find our new home. Carie asked many questions to know how to help us and answered all of our many questions. She was patient, kind, knowledgeable and confident. She was helpful in addressing a few issues we encountered during the process of buying our home. We highly recommend Carie and would absolutely use her again!
-- Debbie Bonaquist
Jan 03, 2026
Property
7040 Bordeaux Court, Dublin, Ohio, 43017
We met Carie when she helped us find our home of the last 9 years. When we decided to downsize, we called Carie again. She was instrumental in helping recommend a number of touch ups to the house that helped us ultimately get well above ask. We could always count on Carie for finding resources we needed in the sell/move, being responsive, professional, and caring.
-- Greg Tacchetti
Nov 24, 2025
Property
2162 Oakmount Road, Upper Arlington, Ohio, 43221
Carie is terrific, she knows the market and is a true professional. I trust her completely and strongly recommend her to others.
-- Michael LaRocco
Nov 20, 2025
Property
3335 Scioto Run Boulevard, Hilliard, Ohio, 43026
Carie sold our house premarket. She was able to negotiate terms so that we could stay in our home for six months until we moved out of town. She actually represented a number of homes in the area at the same time and was able to sell two of them premarket. Carie understands her market well. She is easy to work with. We were very pleased with the final outcome and sale of the house. I would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.
--
Apr 22, 2025
We appreciated the amount time Carie gave to us. She was very good about explaining things to my 93 year old mother.
-- JOSEPH DEVORE
Apr 21, 2025
Property
4446 Dublin Road, Columbus, Ohio, 43221
We appreciated the amount time Carie gave to us. She was very good about explaining things to my 93 year old mother.
-- JOSEPH DEVORE
Dec 23, 2024
Carie was amazing! Highly recommend. Very professional and knowledgeable!
-- Melissa Murphy
Dec 22, 2024
Property
9313 Meadowlark Drive, Marysville, Ohio, 43040
Carie was amazing! Highly recommend. Very professional and knowledgeable!
-- Melissa Murphy
Nov 01, 2024

Carie was great! She is very knowledgeable and communicated very well between us and the sellers.

-- Garrett Gollehon
VIEW ALL REVIEWS

Login to My Homefinder

Forgot Password

Register

Pixel